The Best Hotels to Book in Siesta Key, Florida

Siesta Key Palms Resort pretty much plans your day for you. Wake up with a short walk to the beach with a cup of coffee brewed in your room. Swap the beans for a beer and the fresh catch with lunch at Spearfish Grill. Head back to the pool for sunset and then have one last drink under the shade of a tiki hut. Want to spice things up the next morning? Swap the beach for the pool, the bar for the barbecue, and skip the sunset for a yoga session on the activity deck.

Go on, pretend you live on Siesta Key while you stay at the Hyatt Residence Club. Rooms come as large as 3,000sqft (280sqm) and are outfitted with oversized jetted tubs, multi-head rain showers, and fully equipped kitchens to make you feel right at home. The beach, pool, and hot tub are right in your backyard with grills, kayaks, cabanas, and bicycles always available to use. While you’re savoring the sunset on the terrace, your kids will feel at home, too, gaming all night on an in-room PlayStation.

The Capri at Siesta makes it mighty hard to get your daily 10,000 steps in. Only 200 steps from the beach, you’ll hardly hit a thousand by dinner. Don’t assume you’ll be able to make a few thousand up walking to your dinner reservation. Your room is within a block or two of the French cuisine at Miguel’s Restaurant, slices at Pizza N’ Brew, and ice cream scoops in homemade waffle cones at Siesta Creamery. Thankfully, the Capri also has a private volleyball court that will at least provide some opportunity for exercise!

Twin Palms at Siesta seems to think that furnished kitchenettes, supremely comfortable beds, relaxing patios, and a temptingly close walk to the beach make for a perfect holiday. Spoiler alert: they do. The deluxe king suite’s separate living space sweetens the deal. Between the heated pool, private garden, and sandy shores of Siesta Key Beach, you’ll quickly realize that the suites aren’t the only sweet things about Twin Palms at Siesta.

Looking for bayside bliss with beachside beauty? Join the club – the Palm Bay Club, that is. This low-key resort on Siesta Key may face the bay, but it’s still within a light breeze of their private beach. Bring your tackle box and park yourself on their fishing pier or take advantage of their private boat dock so you can do a little deep-sea fishing. Does winding a reel sound like too much work for vacation? Then slide into the custom hot tub overlooking the bay.

If sugar-white sand and emerald waves are what you seek, Captiva Beach Resort invites you to soak up both at your own pace. No need to rush about it; you’re just as close to the beach as you are to fresh java at the Toasted Mango Cafe and frozen feel-goods at Daiquiri Deck. But why go out when you can stay in? A swimming pool, shuffleboard deck, and smoky barbecue grills are yours to use whenever you please.

The sand and the surf play their part, but the headlining act at Sunset Beach Resort is, unsurprisingly, the sunset. These homey cottages right along the northern end of Siesta Key Beach give you front row seats to the spectacular nightly performance of the Florida sun’s disappearing act behind the Gulf’s horizon. Even if you merely peer at it from your living room couch or let the glare bounce off of the silverware while you do the dishes, every evening at Sunset Beach Resort comes with its own private sunset show.

Winter, summer, spring, or fall, there’s always room for you at the Inn on Siesta Key. They’ve got a shady pergola to escape from the summer sun and a heated pool with jacuzzi jets to keep you warm in the winter. Rinse off in the outdoor shower after a beach walk in the spring and fire up the grill for a little pregame by the pool during the autumn. No need to bother with a seasonal packing list, though; it’s always flip flop and shorts weather on the key.