The 10 Best Cookie Shops In New York City

Cupcake shops are the big trend right now but Cookie shops are going to be the next big thing and, as usual, New York City already has some of the best. The Culture Trip’s cookie connoisseurs take you on a tour of the 10 best local cookie spots.

Milk Bar

Any Instagram foodie has seen Milk Bar’s famous cereal milk soft serve cup, but does everyone know how great their cookies are? With a really large variety, customers should start paying attention to the less well known options. Have you ever heard of a cornflake-marshmallow-chocolate-chip cookie? No? Well, Milk Bar has it. They also have an amazing corn cookie that is worth a try. Go check it out next time you have a cookie impulse.

Milk Bar, 561 Columbus Avenue, New York, New York, USA +1 347 577 9504

Milk Bar, 251 East 13th Street, New York, New York, USA +1 347 577 9504

Artopolis

Bakery, Pastry Shop, Pastries

Artopolis is a Greek paradise. With a wide assortment of specialty cookies, it feels as if every cookie was made with love and dedication. Try the chocolate-covered nut cookie or go Greek and munch on classic cultural treats such as Kourambiethes and Melomakaronas.

Ovenly

Bakery, American

With some of the best sweets and snacks in New York, Ovenly doesnt let you down with its cookies. Anyone will be happy with their options because they can make cookies that are gluten free, dairy free, and vegan. The salted chocolate chip cookie is vegan and is consistently listed as a crowd favorite. The salted peanut butter cookie is gluten free, but you would never know it. As for more traditional cookie lovers, the pistachio agave cookie is definitely one to try.

Baked

Bakery, Pastry Shop, Pastries

With two locations in Tribeca and Red Hook, Baked is taking over. Their look is bold, yet inviting. Baked features some of New York’s best cookies including the Brookster, which is a hybrid cookie and brownie in one treat, a peanut butter milk chocolate chip cookie made especially for the Tribeca location, and a samoa bar, which means you can get your girl scout cookie fix anytime you want. Schmackary’s | Courtesy of Schmackary’s

Schmackary's

Bakery, Gluten-free, American

If Schmackary’s were in the dictionary, its definition would be ‘cookie heaven.’ Talk about cookie creativity! Located next to Times Square in the theater district, Schmackary’s has just about any kind of cookie you could ever think of. The strawberries and cream will melt in your mouth. The monster cookie is completely gluten free and is as nutty as a cookie gets. The classic chocolate chip is sweet, yet has a salty kick to it. So whether you just saw your favorite Broadway show or had a late night out on the town and need something warm and sweet, stop by Schmackary’s.

Glaser's Bake Shop

Bakery, Dessert

Opened in 1902 in Yorkville, New York, by the Glaser family, Glaser’s Bake Shop is a traditional spot perfect for anyone who wants to feel like a real New Yorker. Located in the same spot for over a century in the Upper East Side, Glaser’s Bake Shop has truly perfected the black and white cookie. After all, what would a classic New York bakery be without one? This old-fashioned, family establishment will leave you feeling cheery and right at home in the big city.

Tu-Lu’s Gluten Free Bakery

Tu-Lu’s Gluten Free Bakery is an adorable little shop with a very welcoming staff, Tu-Lu’s has the look of a classic, joyful bakery while still upholding a level of sophistication and creativity due to its extensive menu. As far as cookies go, here are the must-trys, the oatmeal cranberry white chocolate, the kitchen sink, vegan chocolate chip, and, the almighty of the gluten free cookies, the pumpkin snickerdoodle.

Tu-Lu’s Gluten Free Bakery 338 East 11th Street, New York, New York, USA +1 212 777 2227

Culture Espresso

Bar, Pub Grub

Culture Espresso is home to one of the most beloved chocolate chip cookies in New York City. Luckily for any busy New Yorker, the chocolate chip cookie goes great with coffee. Drop by before work for a cup and a cookie. They are all full of gooey, soft goodness, so why wouldn’t you? The sleek décor and tasty menu is not worth missing out on.

Zucker Bakery

Bakery, Dessert

A small-batch bakery café in the heart of the East Village, Zucker Bakery works to bring a spiced take on the classic cookie. Paired with their delicious, heart warming coffee, these cookies never fail to satisfy. For some ethnic flavors, try the alfajores, which are Argentinian cookies filled with dulce de leche. If you are looking for something simple and special, try the spiced honey cookies. Whatever cookie you choose, you will be happy you stepped into Zucker.

Jacques Torres

Bakery, American, Dessert

While Jacques Torres is known as a chocolatier with the best chocolate in town, their cookies are not to be overlooked. These large sea salt chocolate chip cookies go perfectly with Jacques Torres’ coffee. However, if you really have a sweet tooth, try making an ice cream sandwich with their cookies. Plus, with so many locations, your cravings will always conveniently be satisfied.

About the author

Janna Berenson

Although Miami is her hometown, Janna’s favorite city is a toss up between Miami and Boston, as she is a student at Boston University’s School of Communication. She always likes to be on top of all of the cultural trends. A concert addict and Netflix enthusiast, Janna is the one to go to when wanting to discuss the glory of Beyonc? or the latest So You Think You Can Dance episode. Not to mention, Janna has a serious appreciation for Instagram accounts dedicated to food. She doesn't have the food, but looking at it is just as satisfying without the calories, right?