Where to Stay in Nantucket, Massachusetts

Greydon House is a 20-room boutique hotel located in Nantucket’s historic downtown district. The hotel’s design by Roman and Williams and artwork from the likes of Julian Schnabel and Terry Winters reflects the island’s storied past and invigorating present in every detail. Home to a full service restaurant and bar, Greydon House is well-suited for staycations and getaways year-round.

Nestled in the heart of Nantucket lies The Martin, a 15-room property set within a newly reimagined historic inn, originally constructed in 1803. Inspired by the island’s natural aesthetic, the property’s newly revamped design pays homage to Nantucket’s natural beauty and rich history with sophisticated, coastal design elements. Featuring an elevated color palette reminiscent of the tones found in the island’s sky, sea, and moors, the varied hues of blue, green, and grey, provide a modern, cozy-meets-contemporary feel across the centuries-old property.

This Nantucket bed and breakfast has a perfect location in the historic district, on the cobblestoned North Water Street. It’s just a short walk from the restaurants, shops and crucially – if you have bags – the ferry terminals. Classical elegance meets bright and modern in the 17 ensuite rooms, and in addition to visiting local attractions such as the beaches and Whaling Museum, you can also take afternoon tea on the secluded patio.

Seclusion and exclusivity are the watchwords here, so you can slip into the high-end Nantucket mindset in no time. A lively bar features an eclectic cocktail program, inspired by ports of the West Indies, and the Soho House-style Courtyard is strewn with parasols by day and glowing lanterns at night. Though there’s a discreet members-club vibe, you’ll be pleased to hear that dogs are warmly welcomed.

At this family-friendly resort offering comfort and convenience just outside downtown Nantucket, you can indulge in “mom’s breakfast” – a tasty spread of comfort food – relax in the library lounge, or take a dip in the only indoor pool on the island. A homey oasis with cozy, traditionally furnished accommodation, this 100-room property offers you a range of room choices, all of them centered around three separate courtyards, with an outdoor pool and a fitness studio, too.

Nautical but nice, this motel-style property is just a short walk from restaurants, shops, beaches and ferries. There’s a huge choice of accommodation, but the cliffside rooms – some with paved patio areas out front – are the only dog-friendly digs, all tastefully decorated in a traditional seaside style. The heated outdoor pool is just for you, but it’s less than a 10-minute drive to the notable dog-walking spot of Sanford Farm – where there are loops of between 2mi-6mi (3km-10km) to wear you both out.

This local institution defines itself by its warmth of character and generosity of spirit – the rooms are very comfortable, with the suites particularly beautiful. The hotel is pet-friendly, and children are welcome as well. There are activities aplenty, with a complimentary kids’ club, a state-of-the-art spa and fitness center, plus the rest of Nantucket right on your doorstep.

Built in 1849, this place to stay in Nantucket has been a boarding house for more than a century – but it’s all about modern convenience now. Hawthorn House is the only “invisible service” hotel in Nantucket, catering to independent travelers who focus on exploring their destination. It offers self-check-in and a digital concierge, and there are several options for breakfast within a block of the property. It makes for a hassle-free stay in the heart of the action.

With a keenly preserved New England 1700s design – it’s even registered in Congress – this quaint yet striking property is a wonderful choice if you want to luxuriate in the old-school splendor of this charming island. Close to the harbor and Main St, this historic building doesn’t skimp on the modern indulgences, with beautifully finished rooms and a generous breakfast. There’s also a pet-friendly option, in the form of the very classy garden room.

Light and airy with a luxurious salty-sea-breeze aesthetic, the Cottages – which are fitted with full kitchens – allow you and your four-legged friend to explore the natural wonders on the island. Overlooking the harbor – made famous by Herman Melville’s Moby-Dick (1851) – the Cottages are right on Swain’s Wharf and Old South Wharf, so you’ll be minutes from sunset cruises, lighthouses, beaches and waterfront dining. The pet-friendly Woof Cottages are designed with you and your furry companion in mind.