NYC's Top Urban Legends

Liberty Island l
Liberty Island l | © Wayne Noffsinger/Flickr
Ashley Jones

Every city or town has its fair share of old wives’ tales, folklore, and stories handed down through good old-fashioned gossip, and New York City is no exception. Over the years, urban legends have been formulated by individuals, created initially perhaps as jokes or spooky bonfire stories. However, the persistence and appeal of these legends have enticed many to question and explore their origin and authenticity. Here are the top five urban legends of NYC.

Alligator from the sewer

Alligators Navigating the Sewers

Due to the vast, seemingly endless sewage system in underground NYC, people naturally speculate that dreadful mutants must be lurking about down there — cue the alligators. Various versions exist as to just how people believe alligators got into the sewers, adjusted to their new environment, and potentially formed massive colonies. The account that popularized this legend stems from a 1935 New York Times article in which an alleged 8-foot alligator was found in a manhole on East 123rd Street after being either flushed down the toilet or thrown down sewer grates as a baby. But don’t fret; though there have been a few actual alligator encounters in and out of the city, it is scientifically implausible that colonies could exist underneath the Big Apple.

Empire State Building

We’ve all heard it before, particularly in grade school when we think we’re geniuses who understand acceleration, velocity, and everything else for that matter. If you drop a penny from the top of the Empire State Building and it strikes a pedestrian on the street, it would be enough to kill them due the speed the coin would attain on its 1,250-foot journey down. Well, that unlucky pedestrian just became the luckiest man ever thanks to physics, as this penny story has proved to be false! The light one gram penny actually does not carry enough weight to collect nearly enough speed or energy to kill anyone from any height. However, a roll of pennies is quite a different story.

Liberty Island

Treasure (Liberty) Island

Many say that there is much more to Liberty Island than Lady Liberty herself. In the 17th century, Captain William Kidd was a sailor who led numerous expeditions as a privateer but was later accused, tried, and hanged as a pirate. On his many excursions, Kidd and his crew obtained various valuables, including his most incredible prize, the Quedagh Merchant, an Armenian ship with innumerable commodities inside. Upon learning that he was wanted for piracy, it is believed that Kidd buried his treasure on Liberty Island, which was supported by his residence on Pearl Street. However, don’t be too quick to go searching yourself, as further legend has it that dark spirits have since guarded the treasure — just ask Gibbs and Carpenter.

Cropsey Killer on the Loose

The Cropsey legend is the cautionary tale at its finest, which originated on Staten Island. Cropsey was the vengeful, kidnapping ‘boogeyman,’ an escaped mental patient from Willowbrook State School. He was the reason to go to bed at night, to never wander far, and to not talk to strangers. Although Cropsey was folklore, in an unfortunate event of life imitating art, Andre Rand became a real-life boogeyman in the 1970s. The actual former Willowbrook employee was convicted of kidnapping and suspected of murdering numerous children on Staten Island. Today, the legend still stands, and brave and daring individuals still visit the old grounds of Willowbrook for a spook. As for Rand, he will be eligible for parole in 2037.

Babe Ruth’s Farewell Jersey – National Baseball Hall of Fame

Babe Ruth’s Figure

With so many spooky legends at the heart of NYC, making room for one that is pretty comical is only fair. Babe Ruth was obviously most known for his amazing contribution to America’s pastime. ‘The Bambino’ set numerous home-run records, helped the Yankees win seven World Series Championships, and drew in an astounding fan base. However, amongst the praise and tribute of this baseball slugger, is the talk of the Yankee pinstripes. Rumor has it that the Yankees opted for their signature pinstripe uniform to actually make the relatively bulky and thick Ruth look slimmer. Ruth may have been inspiring in many ways, but not when it came to uniforms. In fact, he was only 17 when the Yankees adopted their pinstripe uniforms.

Since you are here, we would like to share our vision for the future of travel - and the direction Culture Trip is moving in.

Culture Trip launched in 2011 with a simple yet passionate mission: to inspire people to go beyond their boundaries and experience what makes a place, its people and its culture special and meaningful — and this is still in our DNA today. We are proud that, for more than a decade, millions like you have trusted our award-winning recommendations by people who deeply understand what makes certain places and communities so special.

Increasingly we believe the world needs more meaningful, real-life connections between curious travellers keen to explore the world in a more responsible way. That is why we have intensively curated a collection of premium small-group trips as an invitation to meet and connect with new, like-minded people for once-in-a-lifetime experiences in three categories: Culture Trips, Rail Trips and Private Trips. Our Trips are suitable for both solo travelers, couples and friends who want to explore the world together.

Culture Trips are deeply immersive 5 to 16 days itineraries, that combine authentic local experiences, exciting activities and 4-5* accommodation to look forward to at the end of each day. Our Rail Trips are our most planet-friendly itineraries that invite you to take the scenic route, relax whilst getting under the skin of a destination. Our Private Trips are fully tailored itineraries, curated by our Travel Experts specifically for you, your friends or your family.

We know that many of you worry about the environmental impact of travel and are looking for ways of expanding horizons in ways that do minimal harm - and may even bring benefits. We are committed to go as far as possible in curating our trips with care for the planet. That is why all of our trips are flightless in destination, fully carbon offset - and we have ambitious plans to be net zero in the very near future.

Culture Trip Spring Sale

Save up to $1,100 on our unique small-group trips! Limited spots.

Edit article