Art’s ability to transcend language has not been lost on Pakistan. Since the 1970s, Pakistani artists have faced difficulties for depicting the conflict and anguish around them. Culture Trip looks at the challenges artists face when using culture and politics as their themes, and how some of them have managed to avoid any backlash.
Pakistan’s art scene is buzzing with both old and new voices; works that would have once been tucked away in small galleries or elite living rooms have instead entered the public space in recent years. But despite the vibrancy, the freedom (or lack thereof) for artists to express their views on cultural and political affairs at home is an issue that continues to take centre stage time and again.
Destinations Unlocked:Let our travel expert Stefano help you find your perfect Culture trip
Looking for an expert's perspective?Uncover my top 3 recommended places from each continent on the map.
1. GuatemalaAn express adventure for those with limited time off. Prepare yourself incredible experiences. You will hike a volcano, visit mayan temples and witness a ceremony and take in beautiful colonial Antigua.
2. BelizeA quick trip not too far away for those seeking a relaxing mini break. You will have plenty of free time to relax but also some awesome activities to experience the rainforest and the caribbean sea.
3. MexicoAn exciting mini trip exploring the lesser known colonial towns of central Mexico. This is hte perfect trip for someone with limited time off and still wants to turn on explorer mode and do something different.
1. EcuadorA remarkable 8 days adventure through the Andes and the Amazon rainforest. The best choice for adventure seekers wishing to visit the 2 most iconic areas of South America, in only 1 week and no flights.
2. PeruAn alternative itinerary to classic Peru, from Cusco to Arequipa. This itinerary is great combination of highlights Cusco and Machu Picchu with the lesser known Arequipa and Colca Canyon.
1. ItalyThe ultimate Italian experience from the vibrant streets of Naples to the breathtaking sceneries of the Amalfi Coast followed by Matera and down to Puglia with its golden beaches, intense flavours and fascinating destinations.
2. ScotlandEmbark on this great adventure starting from London all the way to Scotland with a true Scottish experience made of breathtaking sceneries, whisky tasting and ..lots of fun! Ideal for train lovers and explorers.
3. PortugalA wonderful train journey around Portugal, from the romantic city of Porto to the Douro Valley, to the beautiful Aveiro all the way to Lisbon and Sintra. The perfect trip to train, culinary and culture lovers.
1. South KoreaDiscover incredible temples, mountains and modern cities on this 10 day adventure. This trip is perfect for those seeking immersion in the cuisine, culture and natural wonders of South Korea.
2. ThailandFrom Bankgok to Angkor Wat to Ho Chi Minh City and everything in between - adventure through the heart of South-East Asia. Taste the delights, see history brought to life and unwind on a Mekong River cruise.
3. Sri LankaA fantastic adventure that showcases Sri Lanka's fantastic landscapes, wildlife and flavours. With 3 epic rail journeys, 3 UNESCO heritage sites and time to relax, this trip has loads to offer at a great price
1. MoroccoAn epic journey across Morocco: from Casablanca to Marrakech, through the blue city of Chefchaouen to the wonders of the desert and deep to the High Atlas Mountains - this trip has it all! Ideal for true explorers!
2. EgyptFrom Cairo to Aswan, this trip brings the land of the pharaohs to life. You'll visit the Pyramids, Valley of the Kings and Luxor Temple and cruise down the Nile in style. This is the perfect way to explore Egypt.
This was evident at the 2019 Karachi Biennale (KB), which was embroiled in controversy after an exhibit titled ‘The Killing Fields of Karachi’ was defaced. It was also true back in the 1970s when artists at the time were only allowed to work within genres that were permissible by the government. What many of them did, instead, was work furtively in hidden studios.
Niilofur Farrukh, an art critic, activist, curator and CEO of the KB tells Culture Trip that while art is a powerful vehicle for conveying ideas, the country is still in the midst of learning how to negotiate with the public space on sensitive topics.
“We in Pakistan have a very vibrant art scene and most of us have learned to work within the system we have in place,” explains Farrukh, who has been active in the field since the late 1980s. “And when I say that, I mean we can be very disapproving; often politically as well as socially, we have this tremendous ability to look at ourselves critically. We’ve come to develop a language in art through which we can get away with saying a lot without being confrontational. However, when it does become confrontational, that’s when we face issues of censorship.”
In 1977 artist and activist Ijaz ul Hassan was being held captive in the prison housed in Lahore Fort. It was no secret that he was deeply opposed to the martial law imposed by General Zia-ul Haq, who had just overthrown the democratically elected government of Prime Minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto.
Hassan had created a poster artwork as part of his resistance movement against Haq’s repressive regime. His work was so fierce in its message that it was refused entry to exhibitions and removed from the walls of museums as fear of backlash from the military had peaked to an all-time high.
For four weeks, he was placed in solitary confinement; he was blindfolded, he had a noose dangling around his neck on several occasions – his torturers were pretending he would soon be executed. But he was eventually freed by the guards.
“I have never been able to distinguish between politics and painting. Politics was unavoidable, right from the beginning,” Hassan told The Independent back in 2007. “One of the reasons democracy is so fragile in Pakistan is because we do not build up institutions such as the arts, which are essential for democracy. I wanted to create a culture of resistance. Art and poetry can express a form of not surrendering and present the ‘other’ view.”
It’s perhaps worth mentioning at this point the man whose name has always been synonymous with protest art – the late Abdul Rahim Nagori. His exhibition from 1982 titled Anti-Militarism and Violence was censored by the government, only for the ban to result in widespread publicity. Just shortly after, the Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists took on the challenge of exhibiting his work, and they did so with success. But as nearly all would agree, the most powerful and memorable exhibition of his career was on anti-dictatorship, held at the Indus Gallery in 1986 amid threats and personal risk. Here, he exposed 62 different national events which debilitated the very conscience of the nation.
Fast-forward to 27 October 2019, the second KB – where about 97 artists from over 16 countries were showcasing their works – faced a similar fate, albeit less severe. Men in plainclothes entered the colonial-era Frere Hall garden in Karachi, where prominent artist Adeela Suleman’s exhibit was set up. She had erected 444 gravestones topped with wilted metal roses to symbolise victims of extrajudicial killings allegedly carried out by policeman Rao Anwar. That same day, they forced the exhibit’s closure and two days later, it was completely destroyed.
Suleman, although deeply distressed by the incident, couldn’t deny the power of art, especially when peaceful protestors gathered outside Frere Hall to show their support and media coverage was on full throttle. “They had to break each pillar to make a point, that’s how much of an impact the exhibit had,” she says. “Their strategy, however, completely backfired. If they had let the exhibit be, 500 or 1,000 people would have seen it. But they chose to create noise, and now the whole world knows.”
Suleman has been referencing violence in her work for the past decade and, she, to a large degree, echoes Hassan’s sentiments. “Especially after 9/11, it was hard for me not to look at violence, the number of lives taken because of it, and use my work to show where we as citizens stand despite the situation at home, despite international criticism.”
While artists such as Hassan, Nagori and Suleman have shown an impressionable boldness by displaying their canvases to the wider public, others have practiced a bit more self-restraint at times. This is what Rashid Rana, one of Pakistan’s most influential contemporary artists, refers to as self-censorship. For instance, he only exhibited one of his three-part ‘Veil’ series from 2004 in Pakistan, which critiqued culturally constructed, negative stereotypes of women. He used superimposed hardcore pornography onto the silhouette of the burqa. “Westerners think all Muslim women are veiled,” Rana told The New York Times. “Muslims associate Western women with pornography. I wanted to challenge these prejudices from both sides. The art audience in Pakistan does not object to nudity per se. But I wanted to be careful – call it self-censorship – and did not show the series to a wide public.”
It’s perhaps the idea that art in Pakistan can be controversial that might drive this sense of self-censorship among artists. As Suleman points out, most people have not yet fully developed the sensibility to realise that an artist’s work is just his or her visual interpretation or artistic interpretation.
“As artists, organisers, educationalists, you will always be concerned by the opinions of the general public and how the artwork in front of them will impact their sensibilities,” Suleman says, adding that artists might avoid being targeted for their works by finding safe haven in in galleries and private spaces which are rarely in the spotlight of the state or the general public.
But she doesn’t hide her disappointment in the reaction of the KB organisers when her exhibit was destroyed. Following the incident, the organisers issued a statement declaring that Suleman’s artwork had not met its theme of “Ecology and the Environment” which the artist fully disagrees with. According to her, she had given a human face to ecology, showcasing how violence corrupts the body and soul.
“As organisers who’ve taken on the responsibility of an important event such as the KB, an event which is a big leap for public art in Pakistan, you can’t get scared at the first sign of trouble.”
Preferring not to indulge in the controversy for it diminishes the rest of the work they’ve done, Farrukh believes it’s time to look ahead. “With every step back, we need to move two steps forward,” she says. “What’s missing in Pakistan are mediatory bodies who can intervene when things go wrong, and they’ll do so without any bias because they’ll be working for all sides. This is the direction the country needs to head towards to make further progress in the field of arts.”
The KB statement had also declared that “politicising the [biennale] platform will go against our efforts to bring art into the public and drawing artists from the fringe to the mainstream cultural discourse”.
In a powerful op-ed written for Dawn, journalist Jahanzeb Hussain leaves us to deliberate on an important point. Hussain, who believes ecology is inherently linked to politics, says: “Taking distance from a protest against state excesses isn’t benign. It betrays privilege, for the privileged aren’t only unaffected by land-grabbing but actually benefit from it. It betrays privilege since refusing to resist state pressure is a way to maintain privilege.”
Volcanic Iceland Epic Trip
meet our Local Insider
HOW LONG HAVE YOU BEEN A GUIDE?
WHAT DO YOU LOVE ABOUT YOUR JOB?
It's the personal contact, the personal experiences. I love meeting people from all over the world... I really like getting to know everyone and feeling like I'm traveling with a group of friends.
WHAT DESTINATION IS ON YOUR TRAVEL BUCKET-LIST?
I have so many places on my list, but I would really lobe to go to Africa. I consider myself an “adventure girl” and Africa feels like the ULTIMATE adventure!
Every CULTURE TRIP Small-group adventure is led by a Local Insider just like Hanna.
KEEN TO EXPLORE THE WORLD?
Connect with like-minded people on our premium trips curated by local insiders and with care for the world
Since you are here, we would like to share our vision for the future of travel - and the direction Culture Trip is moving in.
Culture Trip launched in 2011 with a simple yet passionate mission: to inspire people to go beyond their boundaries and experience what makes a place, its people and its culture special and meaningful — and this is still in our DNA today. We are proud that, for more than a decade, millions like you have trusted our award-winning recommendations by people who deeply understand what makes certain places and communities so special.
Increasingly we believe the world needs more meaningful, real-life connections between curious travellers keen to explore the world in a more responsible way. That is why we have intensively curated a collection of premium small-group trips as an invitation to meet and connect with new, like-minded people for once-in-a-lifetime experiences in three categories: Culture Trips, Rail Trips and Private Trips. Our Trips are suitable for both solo travelers, couples and friends who want to explore the world together.
Culture Trips are deeply immersive 5 to 16 days itineraries, that combine authentic local experiences, exciting activities and 4-5* accommodation to look forward to at the end of each day. Our Rail Trips are our most planet-friendly itineraries that invite you to take the scenic route, relax whilst getting under the skin of a destination. Our Private Trips are fully tailored itineraries, curated by our Travel Experts specifically for you, your friends or your family.
We know that many of you worry about the environmental impact of travel and are looking for ways of expanding horizons in ways that do minimal harm - and may even bring benefits. We are committed to go as far as possible in curating our trips with care for the planet. That is why all of our trips are flightless in destination, fully carbon offset - and we have ambitious plans to be net zero in the very near future.