Michael Anthony's Cucina Italiana
Restaurant, Italian, $$$

Homemade Pasta | © stevepb/pixabay
Nationally recognized for the quality of its Italian food, Michael Anthony’s has been wowing Hilton Head diners for thirteen years and counting. The owners brought their experience of growing up in the Italian neighborhoods of Philadelphia here, and it shows. Their food is exactly as you want Italian food to be: fresh, simple, and only with enough ingredients to let each one shine individually within the dish. All of their pasta is made in-house, which only accentuates the delicious flavors that they combine in the pasta dishes. The desserts are also homemade, so there’s no need to worry about whether that profiterole you’re eating was once frozen – besides by the gelato that joins it on the place.