One of the state’s most prestigious cheesemongers, Fromagination stands out for its high-quality spread of small-batch and rare artisan cheese. The Madison-based deli is like an Aladdin’s cave where visitors are encouraged to smell, see and taste cheeses and learn about their heritage. Sit in and enjoy samplers, served with dried fruit and mixed nuts, platters of seasonal cured meats and hearty soups.
Fromagination, 12 South Carroll Street, Madison, WI, USA, +1 608 255 2430
Stylish urban tavern Millioke in Milwaukee’s East Side district is one of Wisconsin’s more refined settings for cheese tastings with its starched white table cloths, dark decor and mood lighting. The focus here is on quality not quantity — just 12 artisanal varieties are carefully handpicked for their unique and delicious flavors. Try one of their signature boards, perfect for a casual lunch, or book a table for dinner to enjoy local cheeses worked into thoughtful gastronomic dishes.
Millioke, 323 E Wisconsin Ave, Milwaukee, WI, USA, +1 414 278 5999
Founded in 1938 in Milwaukee, the Cheese Mart has grown from a small store to a leading Wisconsin landmark. Its shop stocks around 200 different cheese varieties that celebrate local Wisconsin produce as well as notable and award-winning hunks from 50 other states. Ask the staff to help you pick out a delicious gift box or take a pew at its elegant cheese bar to taste some samples. Teamed with a local brewery, the bar also holds regular cheese and beer pairing events.
Cheese Mart, 1048 N. Old World Third Street, Milwaukee, WI, USA, +1 888 482 7700
Step back in time at The Old Fashioned, where sultry lighting and wood furnishings evoke a sense of vintage class. The focus is on serving Wisconsin’s finest meats, cheeses and local specialties sourced only from small local producers. On the menu you’ll find a delicious beer and cheese soup, comforting mac ‘n’ cheese with Wisconsin cheddar and Sarvacchio, and cheese plates with Wisconsin’s finest served on rotation.
The Old Fashioned, 23 North Pinckney Street, Madison, WI, USA, +1 608 310 4545
Ask any local in Monroe for a cheesy recommendation and they will most likely point you in the direction of Baumgartner’s, found on the town’s historic Courthouse Square. As Wisconsin’s longest-running cheese store, opened in 1931, it hoards a dizzying assortment of specialty Wisconsin types that are partnered with craft beers.
Baumgartner’s, 1023 16th Ave, Monroe, WI, USA, +1 608 325 6157
For the ultimate comfort food, head to MACS — a concept shop and eatery dedicated to serving the ultimate macaroni and cheese. Forget the image of the simple boxed stuff you’re used to — this place excels at whipping up a fancy twist on the well-known staple that is served in a sizzling skillet topped with crispy breadcrumbs. Dishes come in various sumptuous variations: try the Baked Potato Mac, an energy-rich Popeye Mac with spinach and the Ultimate Hangover Cure Mac piled with cheddar, pepper jack and mozzarella, fried hotdog, mushrooms and hash browns.
MACS, 208 Broadway, Wisconsin Dells, WI, USA, +1 608 678 2300
Award-winning Edelweiss creamery is housed in a cute little cottage that feels instantly inviting with its geranium-decked shuttered facade. Inside, you’ll find its own cheeses alongside those crafted by local cheesemakers each brandishing its own label and description. The cheesy theme is bolstered by an excellent assortment of sausages and cured meats, Wisconsin beers, tasty crackers and additional snacks. The shop also sells all essential cheese-related paraphernalia — from cutters to fondue sets.
Edelweiss Cheese Shop, 529 First Street, New Glarus, WI, USA, +1 608 636 2155