The Top 10 Restaraunts in New Berlin, Wisconsin

Photo of Cecilia Ackerman
24 November 2016

Just west of Milwaukee, Wisconsin lies New Berlin, a small town mainly made up of families and young couples who commute to the city for work. While Milwaukee is home to a slew of hip new restaurants, the suburbs are a great place to find unpretentious Midwestern diners, pubs, and family haunts. In New Berlin, you’ll find a variety of restaurants for breakfast, lunch, or dinner that specialize in French fusion, sushi, subs, pizza, and more.

Lagniappe Brasserie

Brasserie, Restaurant, Vegetarian, French, American, $$$
Lagniappe Brasserie, New Berlin
Lagniappe Brasserie, New Berlin | ©Instagram/rileyxboo
An upscale French farm-to-table option in New Berlin, Lagniappe Brasserie is a popular place for all occasions. Serving both lunch and dinner, the menu boasts appetizers like escargot borgogne and French-inspired entrees such as veal, steak, and lobster, using local meats and vegetables from the restaurant’s own gardens. The dessert menu features a board of Wisconsin and French cheeses, several tarts, and homemade frozen custard and sorbets. The quality is exellent and the prices place it at the higher-end of restaurants in New Berlin.

Matty's Bar and Grille

Bar, American, $$$
Matty’s Bar is the place to go in New Berlin if you’re craving pub food. Serving up their prize-winning smokehouse burgers, nachos, and their famous house-marinated wings, Matty’s has all the best eats to accompany a cold brew while you watch the game. From pizza to a range of salads and a kids menu, Matty’s has something for everyone. They are also available for catering and frequently host events for the public.

Big Tuna Japanese Cuisine

While you might not expect to find New Berlin’s premiere sushi joint in a strip mall, Big Tuna offers tasty and nicely-plated hibachi, teriyaki, sushi, soups, salads and more. Reviewers recommend sitting at the sushi counter so that you can watch your meal being made. The staff is friendly and the colored lights create a relaxed atmosphere.

Texas Roadhouse

A popular chain restaurant, Texas Roadhouse is a good place to enjoy some low-budget American fare. Juicy steaks, burgers, and ribs are accompanied by sides like chili, baked potatoes, and fries. Known for its large portions, Texas Roadhouse is a good pit stop for weary travelers.

Kat’s Cafe

Stop by Kat’s Cafe for a slap-up breakfast served all day, or select from their large menu of lunch and dinner offerings. This diner’s decor reminds visitors of the mid 20th century Midwest. Cited by reviewers as a hidden gem, Kat’s Cafe is a lovely country-style joint.

Cleveland Pub and Grill

If you’re looking for a sports bar in New Berlin, Cleveland Pub and Grill has got you covered. Gorge on appetizers like pretzels, onion rings, and Wisconsin’s famous chewy cheese curds. Other pub fare includes burgers, pizzas, hot sandwiches, soups, and salads. Cleveland Pub and Grill is also available for private parties and catering.

Rainbow Restaurant

A New Berlin favorite for over 30 years, Rainbow Restaurant serves up almost any comfort food you can imagine. The restaurant was started by a French couple new to the States, and their French roots are reflected in some of the restaurant’s signature dishes. Rainbow Restaurant’s menu features burgers, sandwiches, and daily specials like beef burgundy. The restaurant prides itself on soups and specials made from scratch. Rainbow Restaurant also serves breakfast and offers a kids menu.

Crossroads Pizza and Subs

A great place to grab lunch or dinner on the go, Crossroads Pizza and Subs offers a wide variety of hot and cold sandwiches, pizza, and salads. Their popular ‘hammies,’ sandwiches filled with hot ham, are sold on Sunday, and are a perfect snack for watching the game. For those who don’t want to miss a play, Crossroads Pizza and Subs offers delivery.

Peachtree Family Restaurant

You won’t go hungry at this local restaurant. Peachtree Restaurant’s menu features Greek-American cuisine with items such as spanakopita, a gyro sandwich, moussaka, and souvlaki. However, if you’re craving something else, Peachtree Restaurant’s can easily accommodate, listing meat, fish, and poultry dinners, salads, burgers, sandwiches, and other American favorites. Specials rotate weekly and include sauerbraten, pot roast, and beer-battered fish fry. Peachtree Restaurant also serves breakfast and advertises gluten-free and vegetarian options.

Vituccis Pizza

A family-owned pizzeria, Vituccis is a popular local joint that emphasizes its customer service. One unique item on the menu is the spaghetti meatball pizza, with pasta mixed into the pizza sauce. Another popular option that is often sold out on weekends is Gale’s spinach pizza, comprised of a cream sauce, spinach, and cheese on a thick crust. Try their bacon cheeseburger pizza for a real taste of the Midwest’s all-American eats.

Cookies Policy

We and our partners use cookies to better understand your needs, improve performance and provide you with personalised content and advertisements. To allow us to provide a better and more tailored experience please click "OK"