The Best Hotels to Book Near the Black Hills National Forest, South Dakota

Hill City is the kind of one-horse mountain town that cross-country road trips are made of. Think timber shopfronts that have borne the brunt of decades of rough weather, an old-school diner with the cracked vinyl booths and a dive bar with a Harley-Davidson sign in the window. It’s distilled Americana, just a 24-minute drive from Mount Rushmore. The rooms and facilities of this roadside inn are perfectly comfortable for the passing traveler, but it’s the location that makes it a must-stay.

Close enough to Mount Rushmore that, if it weren’t for the surrounding hills, you’d have four stoney-faced presidents looking into your window, this hotel is in prime position for visiting the monument. That’s not to ignore the other, even closer, attractions that include Big Thunder Gold Mine and Gutzon Borglum Historical Centre, both within walking distance of the hotel. Nature-inspired rooms, decked out in plenty of sweet-smelling pine and cowboy-themed art prints, create a cozy, nostalgic atmosphere.

Tucked away in Custer, within easy reach of the Black Hills, the pet-friendly Chalet Motel provides box seats to this mountainous region. Surrounded by aromatic pines, the quaint standalone cottages offer an authentic vintage vibe, with quilted bedspreads, tiled kitchenettes and retro furniture. Spend your evenings playing Cornhole or Connect Four, and enjoy picnics in the garden. Got questions? Michelle’s got hospitality down and knows the area like the back of her hand.

The Kleemann House sits on Custer’s main drag in its original hotel block, opened in 1883. This remodeled boutique hotel still retains a strong Victorian flavor, with original encaustic tiles, chandeliers, fireplaces and the creaking of well-trod timbers accompanying you to your room. While each of the five rooms differs from the next in detail, they all encapsulate the period, with heavy drapes, wrought-iron bedframes and bedside lights made from upcycled miners’ lamps.

You’re spoilt for choice of accommodation at this Custer hotel. Pick between rooms in the main lodge, furnished with squishy sofas and armchairs and decked in tongue-and-groove pinewood paneling, standalone cabins surrounded by rustling pine trees, or the luxurious French Creek Ranch. If you’re traveling with family and friends (it sleeps up to 24), this is the option to go for – it includes a spacious outdoor deck equipped with a double BBQ grill, a stone-clad living room with a real log-burning fireplace and a designer kitchen.

This motel has everything from chalets and cottages with a private deck to two-story log cabins and pine-clad rooms. Given the peaceful atmosphere, it’s ideal for family reunions. Play volleyball in the backyard, enjoy quality time by the fireplace, and sizzle your way to a scrumptious dinner on the gas grill. With hiking and ATV trails available, outdoor enthusiasts will also get their money’s worth.

From the Keystone Fire Hall in the 1900s and a mom-and-pop-style diner in the 1970s to today’s lodge, Keystone’s Battle Creek has lived many lives. While the owners are determined to preserve the history that still dwells in these walls, they update the services and appliances every year. Sleeping two and four, the rooms come with balconies overlooking mountains, plus flat-screen TVs and coffee pots. BBQ facilities and a garden complete this personable place.