The Best Bagel Spots in Midtown, New York

BEC | © samalegre / Pixabay
BEC | © samalegre / Pixabay
Photo of Julia Goicochea
29 November 2017

Home to Times Square, the Empire State Building, and a collection of other top tourist picks, there’s plenty to see and do in Midtown Manhattan. To take on the neighborhood, you’ll need your fuel. Luckily for you, the area’s bagel spots are attractions in their own right. Central Park can wait—here are the best bagel places to visit in Midtown, New York.

Ess-a-Bagel

Bakery, Deli, Restaurant, American
Map View
ess-a bagel
ess-a bagel | © Chelsea Nesvig/flickr

When a New Yorker is willing to wait 30-plus minutes for a bagel, you know it’s good. Along with legendary lines, Ess-a-Bagel boasts giant, perfectly plump bagels brimming with fillings such as Oreo cream cheese, Nova lox, and BLT fixings. Trust the more than 2,500 Yelp reviewers, and choose this spot to quench your next carb craving.

Brooklyn Bagel and Coffee Company

Bakery, Cafe, Deli, American, Pub Grub
Map View

Don’t let the name confuse you: while Brooklyn Bagel and Coffee Company doesn’t have a Brooklyn store, its kooky creations undeniably (and deliciously) fuhgeddabout tired bagel basics. Serving Chelsea and Astoria for more than 15 years, this local chain continues to earn foodie fans with doughy, hand-rolled bagels packed with creative cream cheese flavors, such as red velvet, honey bacon Sriracha, and chipotle.

Bagel Express III

Bakery, Deli, Sandwich Shop, Coffee Shop, American, $$$
Map View

Old meets new at Bagel Express III, a Gramercy grub hub serving traditional bagels with experimental schmears. Here, bagels are hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked on-site the old-fashioned way before being filled with signature cream cheeses, such as banana nut, mango, and avocado-cilantro. Tip: Trade in your tired bodega BEC for the spot’s breakfast bagel sandwich, featuring eggs, cheese, and hash browns.

Tal Bagels

Bakery, Deli, American
Map View

A chain so good that even New Yorkers can’t resist it, Tal Bagels brings you the best of Old New York in a convenient (and delicious) bagel form. The freshly sliced Nova, pickled herring, scallion schmear, and lox spread that your grandparents enjoyed are all on offer here, where chewy New York bagels come in the classic flavors you love—and not a rainbow swirl in sight.

Best Bagel and Coffee

Bakery, Deli, Coffee Shop, American
Map View

The mammoth meals at Best Bagel and Coffee are worth braving the crowds at Penn Station—really. At this bustling spot, bagels come hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, baked fresh, and in staggering sizes. The menu of classic flavors is sure to please, a good guarantee considering you’ll likely have to save half for later.

Murray’s Bagels

Bakery, Deli, American, Dessert, Pastries
Map View

A New York noshery if ever there was one, Chelsea’s Murray’s Bagels specializes in Big Apple-approved bites. Here, traditional New York City-style bagels come in classic flavors, such as pumpernickel and salt, and filled with local favorites, including smoked Nova lox, scallion schmear, whitefish salad, and pastrami.

Cookies Policy

We and our partners use cookies to better understand your needs, improve performance and provide you with personalised content and advertisements. To allow us to provide a better and more tailored experience please click "OK"