airport_transferbarbathtubbusiness_facilitieschild_activitieschildcareconnecting_roomcribsfree_wifigymhot_tubinternetkitchennon_smokingpetpoolresturantski_in_outski_shuttleski_storagesmoking_areaspastar
Sign In
neourban hipster fashion travel | © Markus Spiske/Flickr
neourban hipster fashion travel | © Markus Spiske/Flickr
Save to wishlist

10 Upper East Side Vintage And Consignment Shops

Picture of Valerie McPhail
Updated: 15 November 2016
Quaint and undeniably au courant, the Upper East Side of Manhattan is the go-to spot for teatime catch-ups and sidewalk strolls amid stunning townhouses. World-renowned landmarks such as the Guggenheim and the Metropolitan Museum of Art are neighborhood monuments. Hidden between the residential walk-ups dating back to the glamorous era of Audrey Hepburn are these top ten vintage and consignment shops that represent the sophisticated style of the Upper East Side.
Save to wishlist

Encore

A landmark on 84th Street and Madison Avenue, Encore is a shopping destination. Walk up a flight of stairs to reach the store, which is located in an elevated space where high fashion is appreciated and preserved by a tenderhearted sales staff. Fashion finds on the first floor include sale items such as denim, trousers, skirts, and evening dresses. An assortment of high-end luxury brands such as Chanel is ticketed between $300 and $700. Make your way up to the second floor to explore a range of styles priced at $40 a piece. Encore exemplifies how high fashion turns affordable with age.

Encore, 1132 Madison Avenue, New York, NY, USA, +1 212 879 2850.

Encore | Courtesy of City Galon the Ego

Encore | Courtesy of City Galon the Ego

Save to wishlist

Tatiana Designer Resale

A nearby resident of Serendipity 3, Tatiana Designer Resale is among the trendiest shops on the block. This shop simulates delving into your grandmother’s wardrobe; handbags and jewelry, including bejeweled bracelets and beetle brooches, fill encasements stationed throughout the store surrounded by racks of jackets and blazers. Expect to spend at least $100 dollars at this spot. Although it may cost a pretty penny in comparison to other vintage boutiques, consider the Tatiana experience an investment. Not only does this shop offer exposure to the most eccentric, fashion-forward designs from Givenchy to Max Mara – it also sells pieces with history.

Tatiana Designer Resale, 235 East 60th Street, New York, NY, USA, +1 212 755 7744.

Not only does this shop offer exposure to the most eccentric, fashion-forward designs from Givenchy to Max Mara - it also sells pieces with history © Courtesy of Tatiana Designer Resale

Not only does this shop offer exposure to the most eccentric, fashion-forward designs from Givenchy to Max Mara – it also sells pieces with history © Courtesy of Tatiana Designer Resale

Save to wishlist

Arthritis Foundation Thrift Shop

Situated on 81st and 3rd, this shop‘s price tags speak for themselves. Clothes run from $25 to $35, and the highest-priced items will hardly trump $60 dollars. Luxury items like a Christian Dior dress or an Elizabeth and James top are rare discoveries among the typical department store brands and quality everyday fashion found in Macy’s or Lord & Taylor. Peruse the well-stocked shop in the event of finding these treasured daily garments.

Arthritis Foundation Thrift Shop, 1430 3rd Avenue, New York, NY, USA, +1 212 772 8816.

Courtesy of the Arthritis Foundation Thrift Shop

Store-front | Courtesy of the Arthritis Foundation Thrift Shop

Save to wishlist

Cancer Care Thrift Shop

This small gem can be found on 83rd and 3rd. Supporting cancer patients and their families through 100 percent of their sales, this thrift store represents the heart and soul of the neighborhood. With the average price set at around $20 a piece, styles include a popular selection of trousers and dresses, with prominent pieces designed for the career-driven woman. This spot is flourishing with 90s silhouettes – fashion’s current fixation. With the occasional sighting of a DKNY button-down, Marc Jacobs jacket or Proenza Schouler blouse, this thrift store is a pleasantly unexpected shopping experience.

Cancer Care Thrift Shop, 1480 3rd Avenue, New York, NY, USA, +1 212 879 9868.

Save to wishlist

Housing Works

The sun always shines on the side of the street where the Upper East Side Housing Works location stands. Reasons for such an inviting atmosphere may point to the company’s mission to serve the AIDS community. 100 percent of purchases support the lives of those affected by the illness. Peruse racks of higher-end garments from Theory shirts for men to Marni blouses for women. Don’t forget to explore the store’s furniture and home goods selection, which is mixed and matched throughout its layout. Aside from the smiles and jokes passed around by friendly members of staff, the products here make you feel right at home.

Housing Works, 202 East 77th Street, New York, NY, USA, +1 212 772 8461.

Housing Works Upper East Side | Courtesy of Time Out

Housing Works Upper East Side | Courtesy of Time Out

Save to wishlist

Second Time Around

Not far from the corner of 75th and Lexington Avenue, uptown gets a taste of downtown swag. This flavor of fashion comes in the form of Marc Jacobs, Theory, and Alexander Wang at Second Time Around. Here, you’ll find an assortment of printed dresses designed for cocktail receptions after work and weekend derby parties alike. Racks line the store’s floor by style and size order. As you shop, keep their discounts (marked by the colored sticker) in mind, as these mark-offs can bring an uncustomary deal. From printed button-downs to flirty blouses, the finds in Second Time Around will keep you Upper East Side-fashionable.

Second Time Around, 1040 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY, USA, +1 212 628 0980.

Second Time Around | Courtesy of City Galon on the Ego

Second Time Around | Courtesy of City Galon on the Ego

Save to wishlist

Michael’s Consignment

80th and Madison heralds a consignment shop business run on the theory of exclusivity. Before entering the store, one must ring the doorbell and wait to be buzzed into this small, apartment-style shop. Inside, Chanel denim awaits, priced at an astonishing $150 to $250. Explore a selection of Proenza Schouler and Marni for $300, and blouses that ranged from $75 to $200. A selection of silk scarves cost around $100, and Manolo heels decorate the shoe racks.

Michael’s Consignment, 1041 Madison Avenue, New York, NY, USA, +1 212 737 7273.

Michaels Consignment | Courtesy of City Galon on the Ego

Michaels Consignment | Courtesy of City Galon on the Ego

Save to wishlist

Unique Boutique

Located on 94th and 3rd, Unique Boutique presents a shopping adventure designed for the more casual lifestyle. Here, you’ll find brands such as Forever 21, Banana Republic, and the GAP – all of which repute a more accessible approach to fashion – priced at less than $10. In addition to clothing, a large, library-sized showcase of books wrap around their comprehensive denim selection. Home décor pieces include teacup sets, pots and pans, and matching plates adorn a display table in the front of the store. This jumble of articles creates an atmosphere most relatable to a market. The store’s inexpensive trinkets are hardly luxurious, but rather designed for everyday living.

Unique Boutique, 1674 3rd Avenue, New York, NY, USA, +1 212 427 0077.

Save to wishlist

BIS Designer Resale

A next-door neighbor to Encore on 84th and Madison, BIS Designer Resale is the spot to shop for formal evening attire. High-fashion style consumes the lofted, walk-up location offering an amazing selection of dresses, starting at $150. Other sections offer more affordable garments for everyday wear. In the event that you didn’t find what you were looking for in-store, their online shop is equally stunning.

BIS Designer Resale, 1134 Madison Avenue, New York, NY, USA, +1 212 396 2760.

BIS Designer Resale | Courtesy of NY Racked

BIS Designer Resale | Courtesy of NY Racked

Save to wishlist

La Boutique Resale

80th and Madison flaunts a locus of collected high fashion. La Boutique Resale is the spot for high-fashion shopping, from Missoni to luxury Japanese brands, all on a rack in the center of the store. Not far from this luxury presentation hangs a collection of Pleats Please, Comme De Garcon, and Junay Watanabe. La Boutique markets itself as a discounted high-fashion spot, so come here to hunt for those special garments at far more reasonable prices than retail stores.

La Boutique Resale, 1045 Madison Avenue, New York, NY, USA, +1 212 517 8099.