The Top 10 Restaurants On Mackinac Island, Michigan

Photo of Rachel Nipper
9 February 2017

On beautiful Mackinac Island, off of the Michigan mainland, there are a plethora of delicious, delectable restaurants. Read our guide to discover the best places to eat complete with the best atmospheres and breathtaking views.

Brian Bailey | Courtesy Bart Berkshire

Mustang Lounge

With an old-world tavern atmosphere, the Mustang Lounge is a great place to relax and feel like a local while enjoying a flavourful meal and a craft beer or drink. Begin with Mustang’s Mac-n-Cheese Bites, Gouda cheese and macaroni bites fried in potato batter, or the deep-fried clam strips served with cocktail sauce. Or, try some of the Mustang Lounge’s delicious soups, enjoy the homemade campfire chili or ask the server about the soup of the day. The Mustang Lounge is also well received for its burgers and sandwiches. Here, you can try The Swimmer, battered and fried local whitefish from Lake Huron complete with homemade tartar sauce, or the buffalo chicken sandwich, served with ranch or blue cheese dressing. The Mustang Lounge boasts eight beer taps, including Oberon, a beer made in Michigan. During the summer months, the Mustang Lounge hosts live entertainment and a lively quiz night on Thursdays.

Mustang Lounge, 1485 Aster St., Mackinac Island, MI, USA, +1 906 847 9916

JL Beanery at Mackinac

A wonderful place with a local feel, JL Beanery at Mackinac is the perfect spot for a quiet meal. Grab a cup of flavourful, fresh coffee and overlook the manicured lawns that stretch to the water or enjoy an incredible breakfast wrap (with a flavoured flour tortilla) and enjoy the dockside view. The warm, cozy and inviting atmosphere of JL Beanery only enhances the amazing food and drinks offered. For breakfast, JL offers items such as the Walking Sausage Pancake, sausage wrapped in a pancake on a stick, Belgian waffles and granola bowls. At lunch, you may try JL’s gazpacho soup, turkey cranberry sandwich, dill tuna salad or toasted BLT. Make sure to try a cappuccino, latte, frappe, fruit smoothie or fresh lemonade.

JL Beanery at Mackinac, 6939 Main St., Mackinac Island, MI, USA, +1 906 847 6533

Courtesy Yankee Rebel Tavern

Yankee Rebel Tavern

Restaurant, Steakhouse, American, Wine, Beer, Cocktails, $$$
Brian Bailey
Brian Bailey | Courtesy Bart Berkshire
At the quaint blue building with the patriotic bunting on Astor Street, the Yankee Rebe Tavern is an eclectic, delicious restaurant. The tavern’s name derives from the patriot Ambrose R. Davenport, who came to Mackinac Island and was a prisoner of war during the War of 1812. Delicious menu choices include the Cajun steak bites (mini sirloin steaks served with crustinis and spicy dipping sauce), the potato leek chowder and the pot roast sandwich (with melted cheese, caramelized onions and mustard on wheatberry bread). For dessert, finish the meal with an old-fashioned root beer float or a bananas foster cheesecake. Peruse the wine, beer and specialty drinks lists for something more to accompany your meal.

Pink Pony Bar & Grill

Bar, Restaurant, American, Mexican, Wine, Beer, Cocktails, $$$
Pink Pony Bar & Grill is the perfect location on the island for a great drink, a delicious meal and a breathtaking view. At the Pink Pony, you can dine and enjoy Pink Pony punch, wine, beer or cocktails as you sit underneath the pink umbrellas overlooking the water on the waterside deck bar, at the oak bar inside or from the upper patio that boasts a beautiful harbor view. For breakfast, enjoy a fresh berry parfait, a Belgian waffle, a Pony Power Scramble (egg whites scrambled with asparagus, tomatoes, mushrooms, spinach and homemade salsa) or the Mackinac Country Skillet (home fries sautéed with peppers, sausage, cheese and onions). At lunch, you can begin with the smoked whitefish dip (fish blended with cream cheese and garlic and served with pita chips) and finish with menu items like the white fish tacos (pan-seared with cabbage and a cilantro-lime vinaigrette with flour tortillas).

The Carriage House

Restaurant, American, Vegetarian, Seafood
Chuckwagon | © Courtesy of Chuckwagon
At the Carriage House, enjoy flavourful cuisine whilst taking in breathtaking views. A beautiful flower-lined path leads to the Carriage House restaurant, where you have the choice of dining inside or dining below the umbrellas in the outdoor seating area. From here, diners can overlook the beautiful flowers stretching out to the water. The Carriage House, part of the Hotel Iroquois of Mackinac Island, is an award-winning restaurant serving American cuisine. At lunch, the Carriage House serves menu items such as chilled vegetable gazpacho, French onion soup, salads such as the grilled shrimp and asparagus salad and sandwiches like the mushroom walnut burger or the open-faced crab melt sandwich. For dinner, the Carriage House offers delicious entrees such as the pan-seared halibut with grilled avocado salsa, the wild mushroom and butternut squash risotto or the spinach and garlic ravioli with pesto cream sauce and jumbo shrimp.


Bar, Diner, Restaurant, American, Vegan, Vegetarian
Sharon Nipper
Sharon Nipper | Courtesy Rachel Nipper
An old-fashioned western-style diner, Chuckwagon has been serving Mackinac Island locals and visitors for almost 60 years. First opened in the early 1950s, here you may find some of the best breakfast, burgers and sandwiches on the island. At breakfast, try the cinnamon swirl bread French toast, flapjacks with butter and syrup or the Mackinac Breakfast Burrito, with scrambled eggs, onion, American cheese, salsa, sour cream and your choice of meat. For lunch, Chuckwagon serves an array of burgers, like the olive burger, the rattlesnake burger (with pepper jack cheese, jalapenos and chipotle aioli) and the mushroom Swiss. Or, try one of Chuckwagon’s many sandwiches, like the black Russian (smoked turkey with bacon and Swiss cheese served on rye bread) or the Mackinac cheese steak with shaved ribeye and grilled onions. Sit at the counter bar seating and watch the chef cook up the delicious meals.

Seabiscuit Cafe

Cafe, Restaurant, American, $$$
Seabiscuit Café hosts a modern, contemporary tavern-like atmosphere and incredible food. Seabiscuit offers an array of delectable appetizers, like Michigan pasties (house-made meat pies), ‘painted pony macaroni’ (macaroni cheese balls rolled in bread crumbs and served with a tomato cream sauce), tomato basil bisque and Mackinac whitefish chowder. Larger menu items include dishes like the Wild Turkey Pilgrims Dinner (turkey, stuffing, garlic mashed potatoes and gravy), the salt and pepper fish and chips, the barbecue meatloaf and the chicken curry wrap. End your meal at Seabiscuit’s ‘finish line’ with items such as warm butter apple dumplings, peanut butter crème pie and salted caramel-chocolate cupcakes.

Goodfellow's Italian Chophouse

Bar, Restaurant, Italian, American, Vegetarian, Vegan, $$$
Goodfellows Restaurant
Goodfellows Restaurant | Courtesy Horn's Gaslight Bar and Restaurant
Goodfellow’s Italian Chophouse is a Tuscan-inspired restaurant located in the Historic Lake View Hotel. Dine inside, on the large patio overlooking Mackinac’s Main Street, or sit at the bar and enjoy one of Goodfellow’s specialty cocktails, microbrews or wines. Goodfellow’s serves pasta, pizza, salads, wings, sandwiches, seafood, steaks, chicken and veal dishes and an assortment of delicious appetizers, like the fish tacos, grilled mahi served with the house slaw, or the pesto chicken specialty flatbread. At Goodfellow’s, enjoy a watermelon salad, roasted vegetable lasagna, chicken parmesan, fish and chips or parmesan scallops, amongst other delicious dishes. At lunch, entrees include the whitefish BLT (flash-fried whitefish served with Swiss cheese, bacon and lemon-caper mayo), the chophouse Panini and the ‘chicken parm sandwich’ (topped with mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce).

Horn's Gaslight Bar & Restaurant

Bar, Restaurant, American, Vegetarian, $$$
With Mexican-style food and an old-fashioned bar, Horn’s Gaslight Bar & Restaurant is a wonderful place for a night out with friends or family. The current Horn’s building was first used in the 1920s for a pool hall and snack shop and, after prohibition, soon became Horn’s Gaslight Bar. At Horn’s, enjoy delicious southwestern egg rolls with chicken, black beans, spinach and cheese or super nachos with cheese, green chilies, jalapenos and beef, pulled pork or chicken. Horn’s also serves sandwiches like the grilled vegetable with zucchini, squash, peppers and red onions or burgers, like the southwest burger (with avocado, black olives salsa and pepper jack cheese). Accompany your meal with one of Horn’s many beers, wines or specialty drinks, like the prickly pear margarita. Check out Horn’s Gaslight’s website for a list of the live music the restaurant features on weekends.


Deli, Hotel Restaurant, Restaurant, Fast Food, American, Vegan, Vegetarian, BBQ
A ‘Mackinac Island tradition since 1905,’ the Cannonball is a quaint white shack on British Landing boasting a beautiful view of the water, a charmingly shaded forest, delicious food and picnic tables from which to enjoy them all. The Cannonball is the perfect place to stop after a bike ride around the island or if one seeks ‘world renowned’ fried pickles. At the Cannonball, dine on hamburgers, barbecue beef sandwiches, chicken strip or coconut shrimp baskets, pizza, homemade potato chips, corndogs, hotdogs, French fries or onion rings. Lighter options at the Cannonball include salads, deli wraps and turkey or ham deli sandwiches. Finish off the meal with a great shake or ice cream. The Cannonball also offers a reservation-made Hayride BBQ. A wagon gathers customers in town and carries them to a barbecue dinner of chicken, ribs and summer sides, such as corn, potato salad and a sundae for dessert.

Cookies Policy

We and our partners use cookies to better understand your needs, improve performance and provide you with personalised content and advertisements. To allow us to provide a better and more tailored experience please click "OK"