The 10 Best Restaurants In Goshen, Indiana

Downtown Goshen, IN | © Derek Jensen/WikiCommons
Downtown Goshen, IN | © Derek Jensen/WikiCommons
Photo of Marcelina Morfin
9 February 2017

Goshen may be a small city but it is brimming with charm and fun activities for the entire family. Located in northern Indiana, Goshen has a thriving art scene, picturesque architecture, and many incredible restaurants. For a taste of the local flavors, be sure to try any one of these ten picks.

Constant Spring

Pub, Beer, Wine, Cocktails, Pub Grub, American, $$$
Map View
Constant Spring is a laid-back gastro-pub serving up a variety of drinks and delicious eats. The bar features craft brews from all around the area plus other domestic and imported beer, along with a small selection of wine and many specialty cocktails. As for cuisine, you’ll find an array of delicious options made from nothing but the best locally sourced ingredients, including organic produce. Dishes include the Southern Bell sandwich with a flavor profile of Caroline BBQ pulled pork, smoked mozzarella and pickles and the 219 burger topped with cheddar, jalapeños, bacon, fried egg and bacon aioli.

Dutch Maid Bakery

Bakery, Dessert, $$$
Map View
A staple on Goshen’s dining scene, Dutch Maid Bakery is the perfect place for something sweet or savory. This charming venue offers up a variety of sweet treats such as eclairs, cannoli, turnovers, cookies, donuts, cupcakes and so much more. If you crave something savory, the menu offers house-made soups like portobello mushroom; salads such as the smokey chicken; and build-your-own sandwiches. They also offer all-day breakfast. Coffee and espresso-based drinks, along with signature varieties, are also available.

The Electric Brew

Established in 1996 by Brenda Hosteler-Kauffman and her husband Tony, The Electric Brew got its name from what was supposed to be the original location, a shoe repair store called ‘The Electric Shoe.’ However, knowing it would not be large enough, they changed location and became the first coffeehouse in the area. Today, it’s owned by a different family who has added to the already much-loved coffee house. It offers visitors and residents great drinks and tasty menus, plus they roast their own coffee. You can pair a baked good like apricot scones with a café au lait or a cup of soup with a sandwich.

The Electric Brew, 118 East Washington Street, Goshen, IN, USA +1 574 533 5990

🌎 // ☕️ // 🌕

A photo posted by The Electric Brew (@theelectricbrew) on

Goshen Brewing Company

Restaurant, Bar, Beer, Wine, Pub Grub, Cocktails, American, Vegetarian
Map View
Nestled in the former Northern Indiana Public Service Company, Goshen Brewing Company is a welcoming brewpub offering handcrafted brews and delicious seasonal menus made with local and organic ingredients. The restaurant is family-friendly and offers a spacious patio with lovely views of the woods and river. You can expect options such as macaroni and cheese with smoked pork and barbecue sauce; the Midnight Moon sandwich with aged goat cheese, figs and honey; and Pad Thai.

Kelly Jae’s Cafe

Cafe, Restaurant, Spanish, Italian, Tapas, Asian, American, Fusion, Vegetarian, Vegan, Gluten-free, $$$
Map View
Located downtown within a beautifully restored historic space, complete with exposed brick walls, hardwood floors, and a detailed original tin ceiling is Kelly Jae’s Cafe. The brainchild of Chef Kelly Jae Graff, the cafe prides itself on using only the best ingredients, including organic produce from local purveyors. The warm, inviting space is a wonderful spot to feast upon recipes such as the kale pesto-marinated Gulf shrimp with mushroom ravioli and cherry tomatoes; the panko-crusted chicken breast stuffed with Spanish ham, feta, and Italian parsley with a caper-Spanish olive beurre blanc.

Los Primos

Restaurant, American, Mexican, Vegan, Vegetarian, Gluten-free, Fast Food, Street Food
Map View
If you’re craving some Latin American eats, then Los Primos is the place to go. Los Primos’ menu is brimming with zesty recipes. If you visit for breakfast, you’ll find the torta de huevos Española, which is a Spanish omelette with potatoes, eggs, red and green peppers and salsa. As for lunch and dinner, the arroz paella with shrimp and vegetables and the Aztec burrito stuffed with sautéed cactus, Mexican sausage, onion, bell peppers, cheese and serrano pepper are two great choices.

Mattern’s Butcher Shop & Corner Deli

Butcher, Deli, Seafood, $$$
Map View
Mattern’s Butcher Shop & Corner Deli is situated in the heart of downtown Goshen and offers visiting guests not only an array of fresh meat and seafood to cook at home but also deli meats and artisan cheeses. If you’re looking to eat in-house, you’ll find a menu featuring soups, salads and sandwiches. Pair the soup of the day with a specialty sandwich like the The Gobbler, piled high with roasted turkey, cheddar, bacon, guacamole, chipotle mayo.

Rolling Scones

A charming neighborhood café, Rolling Scones is a delightful place to enjoy a tasty menu full of international flavors. Procuring the freshest, high-quality ingredients, which includes all-natural and organic products and those from local farmers whenever possible, the culinary team creates mouthwatering options such as the egg sandwich with onion, red bell pepper, green olives, and cheddar on a whole wheat thin bun. Don’t forget the pastries, especially the famed scones in flavors like blueberry thrill with blueberries and white chocolate and peaches and cream with a hint of ginger.

Rolling Scones, 1100 North Chicago Avenue, Goshen, IN, USA +1 574 533 8050

South Side Soda Shop

Diner, Dessert, American, Vegan, Vegetarian, Gluten-free, Fast Food, Street Food, Snacks
Map View
For a taste of good ole American food, then South Side Soda Shop should be at the top of your list of dining destinations in Goshen. Located inside a building from the early 1900s, South Side Soda Shop has a classic diner feel, enhanced by the dining car that was attached to the building in 1986. The menu boasts dishes such as The Seafood Feast with shrimp, clams and mussels steamed with potatoes and corn on the cob in Old Bay Seasoning. For something sweet, try a float, malt or shake and a piece of lemon meringue or banana cream.


In a space where the old and the new blend together through exposed brick walls, lofty ceilings and modern light fixtures, Venturi serves up delicious Certified Neapolitan Pizza. In fact the pizza is so good it was voted amongst the ‘top 15 most life-changing pizzas in the nation’ by Esquire readers. Snack on some herbed garlic flatbread or fougasse – pull apart breadsticks with San Marzano tomato sauce, herbs, and extra virgin olive oil. Highlights include the sweet roasted red pepper pizza on a red base with fior di latte (mozzarella), roasted red peppers, basil and capers and the white pizza with ricotta and house-made pesto. Venturi also offers sandwiches, sweet endings and craft cocktails and is open daily.

Venturi, 123 East Lincoln Avenue, Goshen, IN, USA +1 574 485 2985

Pizza date with Mum❤️Delicious #venturi #pizza

A photo posted by Sarah Stump (@imperfectlysarah) on

Cookies Policy

We and our partners use cookies to better understand your needs, improve performance and provide you with personalised content and advertisements. To allow us to provide a better and more tailored experience please click "OK"