Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana
Famed as one of the oldest pizzerias in America, Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana, Pepe’s for short, continues to thrive as one of the greatest pizza innovators. Located in Wooster Square, also known as the ‘Little Italy’ of New Haven, Pepe’s maintains the pivotal role as the source of where ‘apizzas’ (New Haven-style thin crust pizzas) originated. It is also known as the original home of the White Clam Pizza, which founder Frank Pepe created from the restaurant’s appetisers of raw little neck clams. Over time, it became popular, especially at Pepe’s, and still remains a pizza staple.
Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana, 157 Wooster St., New Haven, CT, USA, +1 203 865 5762
Modern Apizza
As an influential contributor to the pizza culture, Modern Apizza has built its status as one of the best pizzerias in Connecticut. What differentiates Modern from other pizzerias in Wooster Square is that the chefs bake their pizzas in an oil-fueled brick oven rather than a coal-fired brick oven. Using their unique cooking technique, Modern creates their famous ‘Clams Casino’ pizza, a variation from the original White Clam Pizza, and the Italian Bomb, a classic Italian variation. Due to their popularity, Travel Channel decided to feature the restaurant in the show called Man v. Food Nation.
Modern Apizza, 874 State St., New Haven, CT, USA, +1 203 776 5306
Da Legna
Home of a wood-fired oven imported from Italy, Da Legna attracts both locals as well as visitors to taste their vast assortments of thin crust artisanal pizzas, particularly their variation of the famous White Clam pizza. What makes Da Legna’s pizzas special are two key factors: the oven, chef Dan Parillo’s cooking skills and craft and Dave Foster’s creativity and technique. Using only the finest ingredients, Chef Parillo cooks with over 25 years of experience over the oven as Dave Foster creates an original series of small plates and salads to add to the menu. Combined together, the three components create fresh full-course meals that consist of fresh pizza options, appetisers, complimentary dishes and desserts.
Da Legna, 858 State St., New Haven, CT, USA, +1 203 495 9999
Sally’s Apizza
One of the most renowned pizzerias in the nation, Sally’s Apizza is a quaint pizza joint founded by Salvatore Consiglio, nephew of Frank Pepe. Since its establishment, the family has made every pizza dish individually by hand and baked using the same coal-fired oven. To this day, the restaurant still serves one of the best thin crust pizzas, especially their clam pizzas, in the country. As proof of Sally’s popularity as well as quality, Sally’s proudly displays photos of celebrities and significant public figures, such as Bill Clinton and Kathleen Turner, who had travelled far distances just to taste the rumoured best pizza ever created.
Sally’s Apizza, 237 Wooster St., New Haven, CT, USA, +1 203 624 5271
Brazi’s Italian Restaurant
Brazi’s Italian Restaurant is located in the same complex as Long Wharf Theatre, unfortunately invisible to the general public. Most customers dine here during lunch and dinner hours during which Brazi’s serves a vast range of classic Italian specialties from baked pepperoni rolls to veal and pork chops to pasta to pizza. Though they do serve Clams Casino, a specialty pizza derived from the White Clam pizza, Brazi’s is more known for its special Brazi’s style calamari. In addition to its calamari, the restaurant is acknowledged for its interior design similar to that of an antique banquet hall, giving off a 1980s feel to the dining area.
Brazi’s Italian Restaurant, 201 Food Terminal Plaza, New Haven, CT, USA, +1 203 498 2488
BAR
A bar, restaurant and nightclub, BAR is a new pizza powerhouse in New Haven. Customers praise BAR for its thin crust pizzas, especially the clam pizza and the most popular white mashed potato bacon pizza. Not only is the restaurant known for its high quality pizzas, but also it is admired for its unique architectural structure. Designed to create a relaxed yet lively environment, the interior consists of four compartments: the BruRm, where BAR makes pizza and serves beer; the front room, where large groups play pool and gather around long tables; the lounge, where families and dates eat peacefully; and the Bartropolis Dance Floor in the back of the restaurant, where the space is reserved for nightclubbing and dancing.
BAR, 254 Crown St., New Haven, CT, USA, +1 203 495 8924
Yorkside Pizza and Restaurant
One of Yale students’ favourite places to eat, Yorkside Pizza and Restaurant is a family run pizzeria that has served the New Haven and Yale community for decades. The Koutroumanis family, owners of the restaurant, prepare their specialty dishes, pizzas, and soup from scratch using fresh, raw ingredients according to their original family-made recipes. The cook even makes salad dressings, dough and sauces fresh on a daily basis. As a golden rule, the family provides the best quality of food with the most generous servings at reasonable prices. As a result, many Yale students take advantage of the great deals.
Yorkside Pizza and Restaurant, 288 York St., New Haven, CT, USA, +1 203 787 7471
Dayton Street Apizza
An underappreciated pizzeria of New Haven, Dayton Street Apizza is located on Dayton Street, an unusual location compared to the crowd of pizzerias in Wooster Square. Though separated physically from the plaza of densely concentrated competition, the restaurant is still acknowledged as a contestant in the New Haven pizza war for the title of the best pizzeria in the city. Reviews from the New Haven Advocate determine that the reign of the three powerhouses – Pepe’s, Sally’s, and Modern – have come to an end and that there is ‘a new pizza joint in New Haven that is just as good’. Additionally, reviews from the Connecticut Magazine claim that Dayton’s serves one of Connecticut’s best pies, especially the white clam pie.
Dayton Street Apizza, 60 Dayton St., New Haven, CT, USA, +1 203 389 2454
Alpha Delta Pizza
Open late at night, Alpha Delta Pizza is the most popular midnight snacking place for Yale students, especially during midterm season and finals week. Though it does serve a variation of the famous White Clam pizza, Alpha Delta is actually not known for its pizza specialties. For the Yale community, the definition of the restaurant is described with one word: Wenzel. This invention is a legendary sandwich of indescribable flavours that is integral to the Yale experience. With the recent development of the One Button Wenzel app, which places orders via Smartphone for wenzel delivery, students have easier access to a wenzel and can experience a world of flavours anywhere at any time throughout the night.
Alpha Delta Pizza, 371 Elm St., New Haven, CT, USA, +1 203 787 3333
Town Pizza Restaurant
Town Pizza Restaurant is a small pizzeria that has been involved with the Yale and New Haven communities for several decades. Though it is not as well-known or praised as powerhouse pizzerias, it is still a popular New Haven pizza joint that serves thin crust pizzas with ample amount of toppings in ratio to the crust. Most customers dine at Town Pizza for its New Haven style pies, particularly the clam pie or pizza, calzones and some Greek dishes. With delectable meals at an affordable price, Town Pizza Restaurant is an excellent choice for a quick and casual lunch or dinner.
Town Pizza Restaurant, 25 Whitney Ave, New Haven, CT, USA, +1 203 865 6065