The Best Restaurants in Viejo San Juan, Puerto Rico

White Bean Soup
White Bean Soup | christina-rumpf-qjh-BCHbHis-unsplash
Photo of Mariette Williams
26 August 2021
View

From traditional (think seafood paella) to trendy (pancetta dust on your white bean soup), the Puerto Rican capital is a tastebud treat – particularly if you explore the Old San Juan area. Bring an appetite.

If you’re like most visitors to San Juan, you’ll want to hang out in the Viejo neighborhood – known as Old San Juan – with its easy-breezy, seaside atmosphere. Bursting with color, it’s bulging with art and history, and prides itself on its diverse culinary scene. If you want scrumptious food – Italian, Mexican and of course Puerto Rican – and unique menus, you’ve come to the right place. Here are the best restaurants in Old San Juan, Puerto Rico.

El Jibarito

Restaurant, Puerto Rican, Vegetarian

Here’s a long-running, family-owned casual diner with authentic Puerto Rican food. You step in to find an eclectic mix of art set against walls painted in bright blues, pinks and yellows. Food is cooked and fried to perfection – order the red snapper, skirt steak or beef stew, each served in large portions. El Jibarito is popular with locals and tourists – this means there’s often a wait – and it’s earned a reputation for having some of the best mofongo (mashed green plantains) in the area.

Marmalade

Bar, Restaurant, Wine Bar, Wine

One of the best-regarded restaurants in San Juan, Marmalade is about attention to detail. Many items on the international menu are hormone-free, pasture-raised and locally sourced. We recommend starting with the tiny white bean soup made using scallions, truffle oil and pancetta dust. Alternatively try the lamb tagine presented with chickpeas, roasted almond pomegranate and spiced green olives. Get a reservation well in advance as this place is a hit with locals and visitors.

Deaverdura

Restaurant, Puerto Rican

This is another gem in Old San Juan to place high on your list of must-visit spots. A corner restaurant, it looks pretty unassuming from the outside, but its interiors reveal a kaleidoscope of art and color ricocheting around the walls. Like other well-loved Puerto Rican restaurants, the menu – on a chalkboard near the door – changes often, but all food is filling and home-made. If you have the chance, order the pulled pork or churrasco steak – both are tender and delicious.

311 Trois Cent Onze

Restaurant, French, Italian, Wine, Hungarian, $$$

There is French fine dining in San Juan, and you can find some of the best at 311 Trois Cent Onze. As you might expect it has an elegant feel, with dining tables all set under tall ceilings of exposed beams, hung with stately chandeliers. Top tip: if it’s available, order the coq au vin (chicken in a wine reduction stew), failing that, try the bouillabaisse (fish and shellfish stew). There’s a great selection of wine from Chile, New Zealand and, naturellement, France.

Pirilo

Pizzeria, American, Italian, Puerto Rican, Fast Food, Vegetarian, $$$

You may not think of pizza when you think of San Juan, but Pirilo has a loyal following with its freshly made artisan numbers, served against a backdrop of rustic red walls, bricky details and soft lighting. The menu aims wide – tapas treats include setas rellenas (mushrooms with manchego and mozzarella cheese, green onions and bacon). Besides the classic cheese and pepperoni pizza, there’s a tasty one made with smoked salmon, mozzarella and goat cheese.

Café Manolin

Cafe, Restaurant, Caribbean
This no-frills diner has been around for more than 70 years and it’s no wonder. Open seven days a week, it does classic, reasonably priced Puerto Rican dishes. Standouts are the mofongo stuffed shrimp and the breaded beef steak. The home-made desserts are worth a mention: bizcocho de pistachio (pistachio cake) or flan to coco (coconut custard). Breakfast is tasty and fulfilling. Order the salmon omelet or the Cuban sandwich and you’re all set for sightseeing.

Princesca – Cocina Cultura

Restaurant, Puerto Rican, $$$
Step back in time at this charming restaurant, inspired by Puerto Rican recipes from the 1800s. The menu sticks closely to local ingredients, and the seafood is especially fresh. We recommend the paella marinara made with a delectable medley of shrimp, octopus, calamari, grouper, mussels, clams and prawns. You’re assured a relaxing time – guests dine outdoors on a patio surrounded by plants and trees, and there’s a rum bar stocked with island specialties.

Café El Punto

Restaurant, Puerto Rican, $$$
For almost 30 years, Café El Punto has been turning out Puerto Rican food just like Puerto Rican matriarchs have made for generations. This restaurant is a bit of a secret find – from the outside, it looks like a souvenir shop, its entrance filled with gifts and knickknacks for sale. But step beyond and you’ll find a restaurant doing comfort food that locals and visitors can’t get enough of including fried cheese with aioli, butter lobster tail and baked empanadas. Bring an appetite.

La Madre

Restaurant, Mexican, $$$

Just a three-minute walk from Castillo San Cristóbal, this Mexican favorite is an easy place to find, with its lime-green exterior. It’s lovely inside – jauntily blue and white with plenty of bar seating – but if you can, grab a table outside, in the fresh island breeze. La Madre serves food with Mexican appeal: crispy fish tacos, tasty duck quesadillas and mini chicken or pork burrito rolls. For dessert, order the cinnamon-and-sugar sprinkled churros served with vanilla ice cream.

Sophia's Old San Juan

Restaurant, Italian, $$$
San Juan fans of pizza, pasta and steak all agree: this is one of the very best places for Italian food in town. If you fancy the classic likes of lasagna and spaghetti and meatballs, you’ll be in seventh heaven. Try Tony’s risotto, made with churrasco strips and mushrooms in truffle oil or a moreish Otto’s pizza with shrimp and scallions. One of our favorites is tortellini Loren, featuring mushrooms, sweet peas and prosciutto in vodka sauce. There’s plenty of patio dining outside.

Check out the best restaurants in all of San Juan, and make sure to spend your day by the most beautiful beaches in the city or visiting the top attractions. Book your accommodation with Culture Trip now, with great offerings from luxury all-inclusive hotels to cozier bed and breakfasts.

This is a rewrite of an article originally by Chanel Mowatt.

Since you are here, we would like to share our vision for the future of travel – and the direction Culture Trip is moving in.

Culture Trip launched in 2011 with a simple yet passionate mission: to inspire people to go beyond their boundaries and experience what makes a place, its people and its culture special and meaningful — and this is still in our DNA today. We are proud that, for more than a decade, millions like you have trusted our award-winning recommendations by people who deeply understand what makes certain places and communities so special.

Increasingly we believe the world needs more meaningful, real-life connections between curious travellers keen to explore the world in a more responsible way. That is why we have intensively curated a collection of premium small-group trips as an invitation to meet and connect with new, like-minded people for once-in-a-lifetime experiences in three categories: Epic Trips, Mini Trips and Sailing Trips. Our Trips are suitable for both solo travellers and friends who want to explore the world together.

Epic Trips are deeply immersive 8 to 16 days itineraries, that combine authentic local experiences, exciting activities and enough down time to really relax and soak it all in. Our Mini Trips are small and mighty - they squeeze all the excitement and authenticity of our longer Epic Trips into a manageable 3-5 day window. Our Sailing Trips invite you to spend a week experiencing the best of the sea and land in the Caribbean and the Mediterranean.

We know that many of you worry about the environmental impact of travel and are looking for ways of expanding horizons in ways that do minimal harm – and may even bring benefits. We are committed to go as far as possible in curating our trips with care for the planet. That is why all of our trips are flightless in destination, fully carbon offset - and we have ambitious plans to be net zero in the very near future.

Cookies Policy

We and our partners use cookies to better understand your needs, improve performance and provide you with personalised content and advertisements. To allow us to provide a better and more tailored experience please click "OK"